Defiance 12-01-11

If i were the editor of Defiance I would have the scene just about how it went in the movie. In my ethics i don't think they should have killed them but if i were in their position i probably wouldn't have killed him too. Letting him go free would be too risky for him to reveal their place and if i were in their position i would have a lot of anger built up towards Germans in general that i would probably kill him too.Obviously i don't think killing is right but in the moment, in my mind, i would probably have done what then did in the scene. I think the scene is a good representation of what i think would happen. They showed how the man was scared and how he had a family too but it also showed how they had families too but they were killed.My ethics now are i definitely don;t think killing is right or just in any situation, however if i were in their position, i can't guarantee that i wouldn't kill the man too. In the way i think now, i probably would kill him, just because of the way i handle anger and how it would come out all at once. Overall i would keep the scene how it is now because in my mind, that's how it would happened when it actually happened.